I Totally Would've Had a Threesome With You

Truly a standout of this festival. With a such a simple and well executed charm, this play enamored me. I left on the edge of my seat, my heart full. The characters were relatable and lived in: I believed these actors. The play elevated the subject matter with such a poignancy. The direction was just masterful and really honored the characters. The writing, especially that final act was refreshing. This is the quality of work that makes Fringe so special. ... full review

What a show. The writing and performances were so strong that the entire production felt effortless and completely natural. I found myself laughing out loud multiple times, which is rare for me, and that's a testament to both the sharp script and the cast. Every joke landed perfectly. What begins as a funny look at life as a camp counselor evolved into something far more emotional. The story tackles difficult subject matter with total grace and empathy. It was very impressive and I was definitely moved by the end. It's also easy to imagine this world extending beyond this play. The characters and premise feel rich enough to support an entire television season, making it not only an amazing play but a great piece of IP. ... full review

I Totally Would’ve Had A Threesome With You is a must-see for Fringe 2026. Relac’s original script is funny, touching, and poignant in a way that feels accessible to any audience. Each character is clearly defined and individual, and they compliment one another beautifully to build an unshakeable ensemble. The cast’s performances are equally strong- honest and grounded with just the right amount of whimsy. Alexiades’s direction ties it all together, engaging the audience throughout the entire show. You’ll feel like you’re right there at Camp Forester partying with the counselors. ITWHATWY is Italian Wedding Soup for the soul.... full review

Phenomenal theater. The show holds your attention with sheer dynamism for the duration of the 60 minutes. The characters are well-fleshed out and authentic. They are familiar but not remotely cliche. They are terrifically inhabited by the cast; the acting was a standout element, which is a lot to say about a show so expertly directed and with such exciting, original writing. Full of laughs which never compromise the poignant and meaningful moments which punctuate the show. ... full review

What starts as a fun sexy teen hookup show has immense depth that I didn't see coming. I absolutely loved the tonal shift and messaging behind the play. The writer and actor, Ellen Relac, is brimming with talent in the way her story is laid out and her stunning performance. Don't judge a book by it's cover, this show is so much more than what you may think.... full review

This is one of the best plays ive seen in awhile - at fringe and otherwise. Could see this cast going the distance via off broadway run or feature film!!... full review

This is a superb play. Rarely have I seen such a tight, well thought, and clever show. Truly impressive. ... full review

A teen sex comedy that is anything but dumb. This play exudes the vibrancy of youth. Ellen's hilarious and insightful script is able to navigate the choppy waters of teenage sex lives while opening a much needed conversation about consent and the impact of sexual assault in a young woman's sex life and sex drive and how complicated it can be to navigate the trauma amidst the typical expectations of wild, crazy, youth. Brilliant. Hilarious. A must see at Fringe this year! ... full review

This funny, intelligent romp in the woods, directed by Ava Alexiades and penned by Ellen Relac, will take you on an emotional rollercoaster with heartfelt moments and a ton of laughs.... full review

What a whip-smart, heartfelt, and incredibly touching comedy! The cast had some of the best chemistry I've seen on stage in a long time, firing off the snappy dialogue effortlessly while also remaining rooted in the quieter emotional moments. Ellen's writing transports you not only to the days of summer camp- but to the terrifying journey that is navigating young adulthood. She performs the hell out of a role she has written perfectly for herself, and somehow has also written perfect roles for the rest of her cast. I laughed, I cried, I left the theater feeling lighter than when I entered. ... full review