It is a well-crafted story, irrespective of the breaks for audience votes; but the breaks are also extremely well-handled, with the decision points arising naturally in the story and the votes themselves being conducted in a most entertaining manner.
What I didn't like
I am hard-pressed to think of ways that this kind of show could be done better.
My overall impression
A very funny and skillfully executed choose-your-own-adventure play. Writer, director and cast are all wildly successful at pulling off this tricky show. I was completely engaged, entertained and impressed throughout.