What I liked
The writing is incredibly strong, and the casting has been outstanding in both productions I’ve seen. The second piece was especially fantastic. The actor playing Nitro had relatively few lines but absolutely commanded the stage and made every moment count. The writing and performances also did a beautiful job of making me deeply care about Carl, and I was genuinely shocked by the reveal (which I won’t spoil!). The third piece was equally compelling and provided a wonderful ending to the evening.
What I didn't like
Honestly, I enjoyed the production immensely and didn’t find any major weaknesses. If anything, because the material is so layered and nuanced, it’s the kind of show that benefits from repeat viewings—you catch new details, motivations, and emotional beats each time. That’s less a criticism and more a testament to the richness of the writing.
My overall impression
I’ve now seen A Haunting Revue II twice with two different casts, and both experiences were excellent. That speaks not only to the strength of the performances and casting, but also to the quality of the writing. Seeing different actors interpret the material gave me a new appreciation for the relationships, betrayals, and emotional nuances within each piece. The entire evening was engaging, surprising, and highly enjoyable.
