Review by anonymous
June 21, 2026 certified reviewerWhat I liked
Directing wise, the flowing structure of the blocking served the subject matter beautifully. The performances were captivating (Steve Ditko’s redemption as someone dealing with autism before our civilization understood what that meant was beautifully handled) and all the relationships remained truthful even as they were boldly written. The play was so well done it left me wanting more in the best way. I was not prepared for it to be this good.
What I didn't like
My father was a New York actor, and I grew up in the theater, so it’s hard to fault this show at all, considering the budgeting realities of this ludicrous timeline we’re on. And even as I say this- I have to qualify it- the costumes served well in that they took nothing away- (and I love the choice of all those brown shoes on the guys and Stan’s glasses were on point) but that said, if I had a magic wand, I would re-costume the whole show (and do some hair design) so as to really transport us to those times. Again- for a fringe show? Truly Marvelous. But that’s what I’d love to see enhanced.
My overall impression
As a professional comics creator of thirty years who already knew the story from people who worked with Stan, I loved every minute of this show. It’s good for people to know how important Jack is to our culture. If the team wants a second part to this series, I would gladly help them find financing for a play about Bill Finger and Bob Kane, and the origins of Batman.
